It's got to be Scarab Lord or Realm First! Grand Master Angler. I missed the Cataclysm fishing FoS because of shoddy login servers. :(
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Haven't been back long enough to really get any Achievements, but prior to the system one of the things I'm most proud of is opening BT while it was still current. Vashj and Kael were very coordinated fights. But very fun, shortly after we did it BT was open to all anyway. Was a fun ride though.
Legionnaire brings back sweet memory of 24hr AV and 3 shot'in them alliance mages.
The one i'm most proud of at the moment is Loremaster , wow without a lore would have been a game of bowling ... we get new raid (bowling pins) we drop em ... we get new raid and so on ... but the lore changes that , it gives it a reason for being there , and loremaster proves you wanna understand that reason and the story of the game
Over 9000. It's amazing how many people still don't have it. =/
Glory of the Ulduar Raider. Because I got it with my friends in the best raid to date, I will never forget the moment when I got my first 310% flying mount.
As I am generally too cheap to spend a lot of gold (even though I am a warlock version of Scrouge Mc Duck) but also am an avid collector of mounts one can imagine that going for Mountain o' Mounts was a bit of a pain for me and I was stuck at 99/100 mounts for a long time without any of the cheaper mounts being available for purchase. I had originally intended to get the chopper (and Get to the Choppa!) as my 100th mount, but I couldn't resist buying it as it looks so epic.That said, after a lot of farming on Deathcharger's Reins (over 200 times, yes I am that unlucky!) I finally gave up and started up my very own ICC-achievement run which actually was very successful and it became a run that some of the people on the realm were looking forward to. Eventually most of the players got both their Kingslayer title and the Glory of the Icecrown Raider (10 player)-achievement and the Warlock Mc Duck opened up his mailbox twice, once to get the ICC-dragon and another time to finally get his 100-mount achievement
Must be Accomplished Angler
I am proud with my Old Crafty, because i am aliance player and need to fish this low-drop fish in Orgrimar!
Helping my wife get her finaly can do some other things again :p hope she wont read it LOL :p
Mine would have to be "the Frozen Throne" not because the Lich King was particularly difficult to down, but becuase our guild's raid leader never thought we would do it. Showed him ;-)
My favorite achievement is They Love Me In That Tunnel because, well, they love me in that tunnel.
For me it has to be lvl 60 on my first character, dwarf paladin. Ofc, back then there were no achievements, so I dont know if it counts, but man was i proud when i hit 60 =) I still remember the exact spot where it happend. Was in scholo, on the stairs leading down to Kirtonos the Herald. The last nerubian died and BAAAMMM! 60! i was so happy to finally be done =) best moment in WoW for me.