This site makes extensive use of JavaScript.
Please enable JavaScript in your browser.
Live
PTR
10.2.5
PTR
10.2.6
Raid Composition: GToC 10 (and weapon QQ)
Post Reply
Return to board index
Post by
Rouen
For those of you who have made good progress into clearing GToC 10 or have successfully cleared it, what was your raid composition?
Our only somewhat successful group consisted of (Our guild disbanded shortly after our first real attempt)...
Healers
Holy Priest
Holy Paladin
Resto Shaman
Tanks
Prot Paladin x 2(Stamina Stacked)
DPS
Frost DK x 2(Dual Wield Spec)
Survival Hunter
Arcane Mage
Balance Druid
My new guild attempted to have us
two heal
the instance, which I was highly against. As a holy paladin, I did my best to solo heal both tanks through Gormok (holy priest on the raid). I managed to keep them both up, but I was at 50% mana before the jormungars came up and I promptly lost the tanks due to both the worms beating on the tanks and the Impale debuff on both tanks.
My WoW-heroes link is
here
, I would use the Profiler tool or Armory, but they aren't working for me at the moment. It shows my PvP libram, but I use Libram of Renewal in hard modes.
Here comes the QQ...
I want a new weapon and shield dammit!
Guiding Star
,
Argent Resolve
,
Voice of Reason
,
Bastion of Purity
,
Vigilant Ward
, none of it ever friggin drops! I had
Hammer of the Astral Plane
until 5 man ToC came out... then I got to get a WOOHOO.... 36 spellpower upgrade. Make more BS craftable weapons Blizz!
I think I'm cursed, I never roll anything above a 30 (Our new guild uses a standard roll system for loot, wtf?). When Bastion of Purity finally dropped, I rolled a 36 and the only other person who wanted it, a resto shammy, rolls a 100.
Post by
449558
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Post by
Orranis
You're unlucky, tough luck. I get it to. Try for DKP system.
Post by
Rubendesmet619
what's wrong with the standard /roll system?
It's a freaking guildrun, Guilds using /roll=fail because they can't gear up the people they need and people leave because they get frustrated seeing idiots run of with their (if used DKP or EP/GP) rightfully earned loot.
If they're not going to use another loottype I realy REALY advice to switch guilds.
About your QQ.
I did ToGC25 with a betrayer of humanity and stil now only have 232DPS weapons as fury, I have NEVER seen the butcher or the Ony sword drop of 255DPS clearing it every week since release.
so on that part I say QQ more.
Post by
MischievousLoki
If they're not going to use another loottype I realy REALY advice to switch guilds.Well he said his guild disbanded so I don't think it's an issue anymore.
Post by
Drefanator
If you're new to a guild, why are you upset about the standard random /roll system? Wouldn't you hate it more if you were in a guild with a defined system where they work their way down to you? At least you get a chance to roll for something.
Post by
Rouen
I haven't checked this at all since I created it. I think it's funny that no one had a reply to the main purpose of the post, which is raid composition of GToC 10. (I'm disappointed in you Loki! :-D )
what's wrong with the standard /roll system?
It's fine for 5 man runs and pug raids, but unfair to guild runs. In ToC, using the loot rules they do, you could walk out with six pieces of gear. (I was clarified on the new guild rules, one piece of loot per boss and one trophy per raid, all done via /roll)
You're unlucky, tough luck. I get it to. Try for DKP system.
DKP benefits people who have been in a guild and raided for ages, EPGP is a much better system for keeping new recruits around. /roll is just WoW Vegas style. Last night I rolled a 8 on the Boots of the Courageous and a 9 on Bastion of Purity. I won them both just because no one else wanted them, I'm not complaining, but my rolls are extremely low all the time.
I did ToGC25 with a betrayer of humanity and stil now only have 232DPS weapons as fury, I have NEVER seen the butcher or the Ony sword drop of 255DPS clearing it every week since release.
so on that part I say QQ more.
I would kill for a 232 weapon, but only caster staves and several two handed swords have dropped thus far in ToC 10/25. So I'll QQ MOAR :)
Well he said his guild disbanded so I don't think it's an issue anymore.
This is the current guild system. My old guild used Suicide Kings which I was much more happy with then the /roll system.
If you're new to a guild, why are you upset about the standard random /roll system? Wouldn't you hate it more if you were in a guild with a defined system where they work their way down to you? At least you get a chance to roll for something.
For the most part, you are right about this. This guild is loosely organized and does not have many more then maybe 10 dedicated raiders in the 25 man group, so I would climb the ranks pretty darn quickly for spell power plate, which only holy paladins use. The exception to this would be rings, trinkets, weapons and a shield. I'm not worried about a necklace even though it is 219.
Post by
soccergenius
My guild's second group just completed 10 ToC heroic (which I'm a part of =P), and we three heal it
up to
Anub, where we prefer the extra dps. Just a tip on Northrend Beasts, paladins can bubble (Hand of Protection) the impale debuff off before the worms come up >.^
Post by
Rouen
What was the raid comp that you used for downing the instance? Was it comparable to what I listed in my OP or something different?
Post by
soccergenius
My group was Resto Druid, Disc Priest, Disc/Shadow Priest, Prot Pally, Blood DK tank, Ret Pally 2x, SV Hunter, Enhancement Shaman, and a Feral Druid.
Post by
146010
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Post by
goreblade
pardon me for being a bit offtopic, but what does EPGP stand for? how does the system work?
Post Reply
You are not logged in. Please
log in
to post a reply or
register
if you don't already have an account.