This site makes extensive use of JavaScript.
Please enable JavaScript in your browser.
Live
PTR
10.2.7
PTR
10.2.6
Beta
Hellscream Slicer
Post Reply
Return to board index
Post by
SgtShinobi
Tonight, after defeating Anub'arak, I was very pleased and excited to see that the
Hellscream Slicer
had dropped. I am using
Insanity's Grip
in my MH and
Vulmir, the Northern Tempest
in my OH. So, I was thinking that I was going to get a nice new MH weapon. However, one of the rogues in the group was
Hack and Slash
spec and wanted the axe. He just went HnS today and is using
Malice
MH and
Blood Fury
OH. He was given the axe because it was "Better for the rogue anyways." My question is, am I wrong in feeling that I was just robbed of my BiS MH/OH Weapon?
tl;dr Are Hack and Slash rogues still baddies?
Post by
Tenshigure
Yikes, this is a tough one...seeing as the Hellscream Slicer is also a BiS for the Rogue as well as you. To be honest, it could've gone either way, and it should've gone down to a roll between the two of you (unless you guys have a DKP system set up in your guild).
Honestly, it's a split decision here for me. Yea, it sucks that you didn't get it, but hopefully it'll drop again soon (and definitely try to swing it that you can get it the next time it does drop).
Post by
alpha5099
Not an expert on rogues, but the only part I'm skeptical of is his claim that it's "better for rogues." It seems pretty much perfectly itemized for an Enh shaman, and I'm sure the same is true for rogues, but I don't think it's fair to say it's better for him.
Post by
lucius
If he was an Orc Rogue, I'd give it to him before a Tauren Shaman.
Post by
66520
The intention of us sharing axes with rogues is that they're equally good for both of us.
It's an issue with your loot system, not with the loot.
Post by
Kimi3013
If it's BiS for both, then it's a toss up really, live with it. Yes it's got perfect number for Enha (haste = win, no armpen = win) against rogue (haste = alright, no armpen = fail), but you'll get it next time, big woop.
The problem I have with rogue's using axes is
Blood Fury
, why does it exist? It's crap for everyone else isn't it? Or do DKs use fast OH too (I though they wanted slow/slow too)? And even if is useful for the DKs, then it could have been a sword with no problems at all, or they could use the fast sword which is about too (I'd guess, there normally is one).
Post by
SgtShinobi
If he was an Orc Rogue, I'd give it to him before a Tauren Shaman.
The rogue was Undead.
Post by
242837
This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
Post Reply
You are not logged in. Please
log in
to post a reply or
register
if you don't already have an account.